|
Post by Admin on Jun 21, 2017 18:25:59 GMT
Gary
When producing my solution to exercise 11, I came across a possible error in the book which at the time I documented in my solution. So that you have access to it without looking at my solution I reproduce it below:
Although subsection 1 Integration along a Circular Arc, of section VI Power Functions on page 395 of the book claims to be a generalisation to a general integer power $w=z^m$, it seems to me that it needs a slight modification to the equations on page 396 to accommodate values of $m<-1$. If we define $n\equiv m+1$ as in subsection 2 Complex Inversion as a Limiting Case*, then when $n<0~(m<-1)$ we need to rewrite the line below figure 17 on page 396, which in the book (year 2000 printing) is written thus
$\rho\widetilde{\phi}=|\widetilde{\Delta}|~~~~~\implies~~~~~\rho=\dfrac{A^{m+1}}{m+1}$.
This is because when $n=m+1<0$, $\widetilde{\phi}=(m+1)\phi=n\phi<0$ and so we should write
$\rho|\widetilde{\phi}|=|\widetilde{\Delta}|~~~\implies~~~~\rho=\dfrac{A^{m+1}}{|m+1|}$
and the turning angle for $\widetilde{\Delta}$ is $\widetilde{\phi}=n\phi$, positive when $n$ is positive and negative when $n$ is negative.
Vasco
|
|
Gary
GaryVasco
Posts: 3,352
|
Post by Gary on Jun 23, 2017 21:50:46 GMT
Gary When producing my solution to exercise 11, I came across a possible error in the book which at the time I documented in my solution. So that you have access to it without looking at my solution I reproduce it below: Although subsection 1 Integration along a Circular Arc, of section VI Power Functions on page 395 of the book claims to be a generalisation to a general integer power $w=z^m$, it seems to me that it needs a slight modification to the equations on page 396 to accommodate values of $m<-1$. If we define $n\equiv m+1$ as in subsection 2 Complex Inversion as a Limiting Case*, then when $n<0~(m<-1)$ we need to rewrite the line below figure 17 on page 396, which in the book (year 2000 printing) is written thus $\rho\widetilde{\phi}=|\widetilde{\Delta}|~~~~~\implies~~~~~\rho=\dfrac{A^{m+1}}{m+1}$. This is because when $n=m+1<0$, $\widetilde{\phi}=(m+1)\phi=n\phi<0$ and so we should write $\rho|\widetilde{\phi}|=|\widetilde{\Delta}|~~~\implies~~~~\rho=\dfrac{A^{m+1}}{|m+1|}$ and the turning angle for $\widetilde{\Delta}$ is $\widetilde{\phi}=n\phi$, positive when $n$ is positive and negative when $n$ is negative. Vasco Vasco, In answer to your notification: My opinion on any question requiring insight into the model of integration along a circular arc would not be very reliable at this point, but regarding your point, it seems clear that $\rho$ and $A$ are required to be positive, so if $m < -1$, the quotient must be written in absolute brackets. Then, since it seems conceivable that $\phi$ could be negative while $\widetilde{\Delta}$ is either negative or positive, we would also need $|\widetilde{\Delta}|$ as you have it. So you must be correct. I'm afraid I haven't worked with the model enough to know whether the quotient itself is correct for m < -1. Gary
|
|